Dear Authors,
Thank you for your great work on the HAROOD paper. I am currently studying your research and trying to reproduce the experiments.
However, I noticed a discrepancy regarding the description of the "four domains" mentioned in the paper:
In the Abstract: In this paper, we fill this gap by proposing HAROOD, a comprehensive benchmark for HAR in OOD settings. We define 4 OOD scenarios: cross-person, cross-position, cross-dataset, and cross-time, and build a testbed covering 6 datasets, 16 comparative methods (implemented with CNN-based and Transformerbased architectures), and two model selection protocols.
In the Main Text: HAROOD includes six publicly available time-series sensor datasets and supports four domain-shift scenarios: cross-person, cross-position, cross-device, and cross-time.
Could you please clarify which definition corresponds to the actual experimental setting? I might have misunderstood some context, but I would appreciate your guidance to ensure I understand the setup correctly.
Thank you for your time!
Best regards
Dear Authors,
Thank you for your great work on the HAROOD paper. I am currently studying your research and trying to reproduce the experiments.
However, I noticed a discrepancy regarding the description of the "four domains" mentioned in the paper:
In the Abstract: In this paper, we fill this gap by proposing HAROOD, a comprehensive benchmark for HAR in OOD settings. We define 4 OOD scenarios: cross-person, cross-position, cross-dataset, and cross-time, and build a testbed covering 6 datasets, 16 comparative methods (implemented with CNN-based and Transformerbased architectures), and two model selection protocols.
In the Main Text: HAROOD includes six publicly available time-series sensor datasets and supports four domain-shift scenarios: cross-person, cross-position, cross-device, and cross-time.
Could you please clarify which definition corresponds to the actual experimental setting? I might have misunderstood some context, but I would appreciate your guidance to ensure I understand the setup correctly.
Thank you for your time!
Best regards